Substantiating investment valuation disclosures in your annual report
ASIC’s latest superannuation review gives reporting teams a practical reason to examine the evidence, explanations and approvals behind their published valuation disclosures.
A valuation can pass through several teams before it appears in a super fund’s financial report. Investment specialists assess the assets, finance prepares the disclosures, and reviewers consider whether the figures and explanations are appropriate. Each handover needs to preserve the connection between the information received and the content ultimately published.
For annual reporting teams, that creates a specific governance question: can you demonstrate how the valuation disclosures were prepared, substantiated and approved?
What ASIC found
In October 2026, ASIC published REP 841, reporting findings from its review of 42 superannuation financial reports and six audits. It identified continuing weaknesses in the scrutiny of unlisted investment valuations. (asic.gov.au)
RSE financial reports
ASIC’s review of financial reports found:
- trustees often relied on external fund managers to provide fair value information for externally managed unlisted investments, which may limit their ability to review and challenge significant valuation assumptions and estimates
- some trustees did not adjust member liabilities in a timely manner following significant investment write-downs, and
- fair value hierarchy disclosures continue to only provide high-level descriptions and references to external pricing sources, with limited information about the valuation techniques, inputs and judgements used. This makes it difficult for members to understand how some fair values were determined and the uncertainty involved.
The regulator said its 2026–27 financial reporting and audit surveillance would extend to managed investment schemes.
How to demonstrate governance
Give each disclosure a clear basis
Reporting teams can use these findings to examine how supporting information reaches the financial report. A figure may have an identified source, while the surrounding explanation has been carried forward from an earlier reporting period. Both need review.
For example, if an investment’s valuation approach changes, the team should consider whether the description of that approach still reflects the approved assessment. The review should address the reporting requirements applicable to the fund and the information needed to explain material judgements.
A practical process records the source and reporting date, identifies the specialist responsible for checking the content, and retains the evidence considered. That gives subsequent reviewers a basis for evaluating the disclosure rather than reconstructing its history.
Make review responsibilities specific
A request to approve an entire annual report can leave uncertainty about the scope of each person’s review. Finance, investment specialists and legal reviewers may each assume another team has checked a particular explanation.
Assign responsibility at the relevant section. Ask investment specialists to review descriptions of valuation methods and assumptions, while finance considers the figures and financial reporting requirements. Resolve questions before the content moves to final approval.
The review record should explain what was checked and capture outstanding issues. Where a reviewer challenges a description, retain the question and the resolution alongside the content. This helps the next reporting cycle begin with a usable record of the previous decision.
Keep late changes connected to approval
Annual reports often change close to publication. An updated valuation, revised note or new explanation can affect content that has already been reviewed.
Consider a hypothetical late adjustment to a reported value. The team may also need to revisit a related table and the commentary explaining the movement. Updating the number alone leaves the review incomplete.
A controlled process identifies affected content, sends it back to the appropriate reviewers and preserves the version that receives final approval. The published output should be checked against that approved version, including changes made during formatting.
How Objective Keystone supports the disclosure process
Objective Keystone brings drafting, review, verification and publishing into one controlled environment, with effortless governance built in. Teams can assign sections to reviewers, retain supporting commentary and generate verification certificates associated with approved content showing who approved what and when.
Objective Keystone’s Data Models can extract and synchronise data from Excel or core business systems, with governed transformations into the desired data format for reporting, while capturing version history. Reporting teams can use a point-in-time snapshot and preview data in document context during review. Data incorporated into disclosures is subject to the same built-in verification controls as the surrounding content.
Reusable content and publishing from verified source content help reduce manual copying between approved material and final outputs. These capabilities support the preparation and governance of disclosure.
Explore how Objective Keystone can support the drafting, verification and publication of your annual report disclosures.